4. Reclaiming Your Agency

You Can Have Authority Without Having Agency

You may have authority over hundreds of people, a multimillion-dollar budget, and decisions that affect the future of an organization—and still have surprisingly little agency over the direction of your own life.

It sounds contradictory. Senior leaders make decisions all day long. They allocate resources, set priorities, hire people, solve problems, approve strategies, and make judgment calls with significant consequences. From the outside, they may appear to have more agency than almost anyone around them.

But many of those decisions are made within structures someone else created: Here is the budget. Here are the corporate priorities. Here is your role. Here are the expectations. Here is what success looks like. And, if all goes well, here is the next rung on the ladder.

Over time, you can become extraordinarily successful at choosing among the choices presented to you without stopping to ask whether those are the choices you want. That's authority without agency.

When Did Someone Else Start Defining "Great"?

In the first article of this Your Next Chapter series, we began talking about establishing your own criteria for "great." Since then, we've turned down the noise enough to hear ourselves think and looked for the Red Thread that helps us understand the pattern running through our careers.

Now comes a more challenging step. What are you going to do with what you're hearing? Hearing your own voice is one thing. Giving it authority is another.

Perhaps you're hearing yourself say, I don't want to live like this anymore. And almost immediately, you may hear the voices of others in your head saying:

Don't be ungrateful. People would love to have your position.

That's simply what senior leadership requires.

You've worked too hard to walk away now.

You make too much money to consider something else.

At your age, you can't afford to be picky.

Some of those messages may have been spoken to us directly. Others may simply reflect what we've internalized over decades about success, ambition, responsibility, and what someone at our level is supposed to want. Reclaiming agency begins when we stop automatically accepting those scripts as instructions.

Sometimes It's Easier to Start With "Never Again"

When I work with a senior executive who is considering their next chapter, one of the first things we need to clarify is what they're actually looking for. Surprisingly, it is often easier to identify what we do want by first naming what we don't want to repeat in our next chapter.

I've found a simple exercise helpful. Start with the experience you don't want to repeat. Then ask what that experience tells you must be different next time.

Those "never agains" aren't merely complaints about the past. They are data about our desired future. And they can help you refine something we began exploring in the first article of this series: your own criteria for great.

Great may once have meant a bigger title, broader scope, more compensation, or greater prestige. Now, great may also mean autonomy. Time to think. Work that uses more of you. People you respect. The freedom to create. A life in which work matters enormously but doesn't consume everything else that matters.

From Preferences to Conditions of Satisfaction

This is where agency begins to become practical. There is a difference between saying, I'd like more flexibility, and deciding, My next chapter must give me meaningful control over my time.

There's a difference between I hope I have a good boss and I will only work in an environment where my expertise and judgment are trusted.

There's a difference between I'd love to do something more meaningful and My next chapter must allow me to make a contribution I consider worthwhile.

The first versions are preferences.

The second begin to become Conditions of Satisfaction: the conditions that need to be present for an opportunity, role, or next chapter to work for you.

Not every preference can or should become non-negotiable. Life involves tradeoffs. But if you don't know which conditions matter most, it's remarkably easy to be seduced by an impressive title, generous compensation package, or prestigious opportunity—and discover later that you've recreated precisely the circumstances you wanted to leave.

Agency means deciding which criteria get a vote before the opportunity arrives.

You Don't Have to Make It Wrong to Say No

There's another freedom that comes with reclaiming agency: recognizing that you don't have to prove an opportunity is bad before deciding it isn't right for you. The company may be excellent. The compensation may be generous. The title may be impressive. Your colleagues may think you'd be crazy to turn it down.

And it still may not meet your Conditions of Satisfaction.

An opportunity can be objectively excellent and still be wrong for you.

That's an important distinction for accomplished people who have spent much of their careers learning how to compete for—and win—desirable opportunities. Agency allows you to ask a different question: Desirable to whom?

What Do You Want to Reclaim?

Reclaiming agency isn't only about what you refuse to tolerate. It's also about what you refuse to leave behind any longer.

Perhaps you've missed writing. Creating. Teaching. Mentoring. Building relationships. Solving difficult problems. Learning something completely new. Perhaps there's a capability you once loved using that increasing responsibilities gradually pushed to the margins. Or perhaps there's simply a part of yourself you haven't heard from in a very long time.

Your next chapter may give you an opportunity not merely to leave something behind, but to reclaim something of yourself. That belongs in your criteria for great, too.

Becoming the Author of Your Criteria

Reclaiming agency doesn't require quitting your job, rejecting ambition, or making a dramatic life change. It means becoming the author of the criteria by which you will make your next choices.

You may have spent decades becoming exceptionally good at succeeding within structures other people created. Your next chapter asks something different of you: What do you want to create?

That question isn't selfish. Nor does it mean ignoring responsibilities, relationships, or practical realities. It means recognizing that your values, energy, aspirations, and definition of a satisfying life belong in the decision-making process too.

Your next chapter shouldn't simply happen to you. You get to help decide what it will require of you—and what it will give back.

Your Authority Brief™ Micro-Action

Take a notebook and complete this sentence five times:

In my next chapter, I am no longer willing to ____________________.

Don't make the answers sound reasonable or impressive. Make them true.

Then return to each answer and ask:

What does this tell me I need instead?

Now add one more question:

What part of myself do I want to reclaim?

Your "never agains" are signposts. Your answers can begin revealing the Conditions of Satisfaction that will help you recognize a next chapter worth choosing.

That's what reclaiming agency looks like: not simply choosing among the options presented to you, but deciding what must be true before you say yes.