
2. Just Say No to Toxic Yeses
When my friend Sally (name changed) and I spoke recently, she was exhausted and frustrated. She had agreed to another urgent volunteer assignment, even though her calendar was already full.
Of course she could do it. She had stepped in for this organization many times before and consistently delivered excellent work. But this latest commitment was crowding out things she wanted—and needed—to do for herself.
She wondered why these requests always seemed to land with her. I pointed out that she had become the obvious person to ask: she usually said yes, and people knew she would do the job well. What she needed now was help saying no.
This lesson is for Sally—and for those of us who recognize ourselves in her experience. Being capable, dependable, and generous can make us the person everyone asks. Answering deliberately helps us decide which requests belong in our lives.
In Lesson 1, we identified something you wanted in your next chapter and turned it into a small experiment. Now comes a practical challenge: protecting that choice when someone asks us for something else.
What makes a yes toxic?
A toxic yes happens when you agree to something to avoid the discomfort of declining—and that commitment undermines something important to you. Perhaps you say yes because you want to be helpful, because you’re pleased to be asked, or because you’ve always been the person others can count on. Saying, “I can’t take that on,” may even feel like admitting a professional shortcoming.
For accomplished leaders, being capable can become its own trap. You can do the work, make the introduction, or serve on the committee. But capability alone doesn’t tell you whether a commitment belongs in your life.
Before answering, ask: What would this yes displace? Consider the preparation, follow-up, and attention the commitment will require, beyond the hour it occupies on your calendar. Would it displace something else you value—time with family, a personal project you’ve committed to, or the experiment you chose for your next chapter?
You may decide the opportunity is worth that tradeoff. The point is to make the tradeoff visible before you agree.
Choose discomfort over resentment
Brené Brown offers a memorable phrase for setting boundaries: “Choose discomfort over resentment.” In her discussion of the phrase, she describes the brief discomfort of disappointing someone compared with the resentment that can accumulate when we repeatedly disregard our own needs.
You may feel uncomfortable declining. You may also feel uncomfortable fulfilling a commitment you wish you hadn’t made while watching something important to you get postponed. Brown’s phrase helps us consider the longer-term cost of avoiding that difficult moment.
Your Conditions of Satisfaction deserve a place in the decision. Naming them is the first step. Letting them influence your answer is how you put them into practice.
A gracious no has a structure
Greg McKeown, author of Essentialism, offers three steps in his article “How to Say No Gracefully”: acknowledge the relationship, express sincere appreciation for the opportunity, and decline firmly and politely. Here are a few ways that approach might sound:
For a professional invitation: “It’s good to hear from you. Thank you for considering me for this project. I’m protecting time for commitments already underway, so I need to decline.”
For a request from someone you know well: “I appreciate your asking, and I know this matters to you. I’m not able to take it on.”
For an opportunity that fits your expertise but not your direction: “Thank you for thinking of me. I’m focusing my work in a different direction, so I’ll pass on this opportunity.”
You can be warm and clear in the same response. You don’t need an exhaustive explanation, and you don’t need to offer another contribution unless you actually want to make it.
If you need time to decide, give yourself that time: “Thank you for asking. Let me consider my commitments, and I’ll get back to you tomorrow.” Then follow through with an answer.
Your Authority Brief™ Micro-Action
Before accepting your next optional commitment, pause and name what it would displace. Compare that cost with one condition you identified in Lesson 1. If the request doesn’t fit, practice a gracious no: acknowledge the relationship, appreciate the invitation, and state your decision clearly.
Your next chapter takes shape through the commitments you choose—and the ones you decline.
Bring Your Challenge to the Table This Thursday
This Thursday, October 15, I’ll join Kate Rosenberg and moderator Kathleen Caldwell for The Executive Advisory Table™, hosted by the C-Suite Network Women’s Coaching & Consulting Council.
Women executives and organizational leaders are invited to bring a real challenge, decision, opportunity, or transition. We’ll respond to selected situations with questions, perspective, and practical insight. Sensitive challenges may be submitted anonymously.
Thursday, October 15 | 1 p.m. ET / noon CT
Reserve your place: https://tinyurl.com/C-SuiteWCCCOctober152026